France National Overview
Updated in July 2018 by Jacques Moreau, Director at the CEFEDEM Rhône-Alpes, Lyon.
Overview of Higher Music Education System
Higher education relative to music in France is provided via two ministries, the National Ministry of Education and the Ministry of Culture and Communication.
Under the aegis of the National Education Ministry, 27 universities provide three-cycle training linked to theoretical knowledge of music which in turn leads to careers primarily in research and musicology and general music teaching (junior high schools, high schools, and universities). In addition, courses are provided in music management, choral conducting, sound design, and cultural mediation. Students may enter university upon completion of the high school baccalaureate. Degrees are the Licence (“Bachelor” – end of 1st cycle), Master (end of 2nd cycle) and Doctorat (end of 3rd cycle). It is possible to study musicology disciplines both within universities (Ministry of Education) and at the two national Conservatoires of Paris and Lyon (Ministry of Culture).
The Ministry of Culture and Communication oversees the professional higher education for performing arts. In music and in all cases, admittance to those higher education institutions is based on successfully passing a competitive entrance examination. Teaching is organised at three levels, according to the French Ministry of Labour: level 1 = EQF level 8; level 2 = EQF level 7; level 3 = EQF level 6). Given the specificities of the French system, the Ministry of Culture diplomas at level 3 (EQF level 6) are not fully equivalent to a Bachelor diploma, as only University can award that degree. Those level 3 diplomas are diplomas delivered by each institution, which need to be linked to a university Licence to be recognized as a full Bachelor.
Those musical higher education institutions are of different types, and deliver diplomas at the 3 final levels of the Bologna System (according to EQF System):
[NB : IN the French System, level III corresponds to EQF level 5, level II to EQF level 6, and level I to EQF level 7 and 8]
- Conservatoire National Supérieur de Musique et de Danse (CNSMD), one in Paris and one in Lyon, which deliver diplomas from EQF levels 6 to 8;
- Pôles d’enseignement supérieur de la musique (PESM), which deliver diplomas at EQF level 6, some of them deliver also diplomas at level 7 by partnership with a university;
- 3 CEFEDEM, which deliver diplomas at EQF level 6;
- 9 CFMI, which deliver diplomas at EQF level 6 (NB: one CFMI – Lyon – offers also a diploma at EQF level 7);
These institutions all propose professional diplomas which prepare students for the following professions:
- Performer (soloist, chamber musician, orchestral musician);
- Composer, Conductor, Sound Engineer;
- Music professors leading groups in nursery or primary schools;
- Music professors providing individual or group lessons in a range of music institutions going from local music schools to regional conservatoires, and even higher music education institutions.
The Ministry also oversees the 36 regional conservatoires (Conservatoires à Rayonnement Régional – CRR) and 105 national conservatoires (Conservatoires à Rayonnement Départemental – CRD). Some of the CRR are linked by partnership to a university which delivers a specific Licence to their students (EQF level 6).
The Bologna system in France is completely implemented: the performers education since 2008 and the Music Teacher Education since July 2016.
Total number of institutions |
|
Total number of music students |
Average of 4.000
|
Funding |
|
Curricula |
Curricula for professional music training are controlled by the State.
|
Genres | Classical music (early to contemporary music): in all institutions Jazz: In Paris Conservatoire and some Pôles d’enseignement supérieur and Cefedem Pop: in some Pôles d’enseignement supérieur and Cefedem Traditional and world music: in some Pôles d’enseignement supérieur and Cefedem |
2-cycle system | 1st cycle: 3 years 2nd cycle: 2 years 3rd cycle: 3 yearsNote: Some Pôles d’enseignement superieur offer Master programmes together with a university; Some universities offer performance programs together with a CRR, outside of any accreditation from the Ministère de la culture. |
Qualifications |
1st cycle
2nd cycle offered by CNSMD
3rd cycle offered by CNSMD
Note: the two CNSMD offer also an “Artist diploma” which is a post-master curriculum not awarding a 3rd cycle diploma.
|
Specialisations | At the Paris CNSMDP:
At the Lyon CNSMDL:
At both CNSMD: 2nd cycle teaching qualification – Certificat d’Aptitude (CA) At the Pôles d’enseignement supérieur:
DNSPM or “Diplôme national supérieur professional de musician”: is a 1st cycle diploma for instrumental and vocal performance students, possibly in all genres, leading to a first level of entry into the professions of soloist, chamber and orchestral musician, accompanist, group musician.
DE or “Diplôme d’Etat de professeur de musique” is a 1st cycle teaching qualification enabling graduates to teach individual and collective instrumental courses in music schools.
At the CEFEDEM: DE or Diplôme d’Etat. At the CFMI: DUMI graduates are in charge of running collective music courses in kindergartens or primary schools. |
Entry requirements |
At the CNSMD (Paris and Lyon):
At the Pôles d’enseignement supérieur and the CEFEDEM, prerequisites are: having been awarded a baccalaureate (final diploma for general education – EQF level 4), having been awarded a final pre-college music education diploma or the equivalent; and having successfully passed the entrance examinations.
At the CFMI, the entrance requirements include the baccalaureate and two years university, as well successful completion of a competitive examination. |
% of students who continue with 2nd cycle | No information available yet |
3rd cycle |
Students can only pursue the third cycle at a CNSMD. In both institutions, Doctoral programme exists (as a joint programme with several other institutions of higher education) for artistic research and/or research in musicology with increasing perspective on artistic research.
|
Credit point system |
1st cycle diploma: 180 ECTS
2nd cycle: 120 ECTS 3rd cycle: 180 ECTS |
Internationalization |
Conservatoire National Supérieur de Musique et de Danse: Those two institutions have a very active and solid internationalization policy, counting many international partners.
Pôles d’enseignement supérieur: Those institutions are more recent. Most of them have already an increasing internationalization policy, some others are only starting. CEFEDEM and CFMI: the INVITE program (Polifonia 2) showed how difficult it was for the teaching programs to develop internationalization. Nevertheless, some institutions have a selected or specific internationalization policy. |
Quality assurance |
1st cycle diplomas: DNSPM and DE
Those diplomas are, by law, registered in the Register National de la Certification professional (national registry for professional certification – the French qualification framework and registry). The ministry of Culture, is responsible for the organization of the quality assurance process. Until 2018, the process was the following: An external commission, Commission Nationale d’habilitation, under ministry of Culture’s authority, habilitates for a certain period (generally 5 years) the institutions to award those diplomas; the process makes use of a self-evaluation report which is sent to a commission of outside experts; the outside experts do not receive any special training. They send a report to the Commission, which rules and sends an advice to the head of the relevant division of the ministry of Culture, who takes a final decision. Since 2019, the process moves to a full global accreditation of each institution, for a five years term, and for all the diplomas it delivers, all in once. This accreditation will be given by a council recently created within the ministry of Culture: Conseil national de l’enseignement supérieur et de la recherche artistiques et culturels (CNESERAC). The quality assurance standards relate to the professions in which the national conservatoires prepare students and provide the knowledge and skills needed to exercise these professions. Standards are used to evaluate how the various aspects of the diplomas correspond to knowledge and skills and how they are validated, in other words the ways in which the national conservatoires evaluate the competencies of student knowledge and skills in a particular discipline. Finally, the conservatoire must prove, in practical terms, that those who have been awarded diplomas are in fact exercising this knowledge and these skills within the music profession through a survey which involves contacting all those having completed their studies within the last 3 years. On an administrative level, the quality assurance process is informed by each institution on its financial, resources, employment situation. Some institutions are under private status, even if having public funds. Other ones are public administrations (Établissements publics). Those are directly under the control of the Cour des Comptes (the French National Audit Office) which verifies the good usage of public funds approximately every ten years, in a two-fold manner: • The Office does an audit of accounts (to determine that spending of public funds is in conformity with the law). This is a juridical process and concerns the institution’s chief accountant; • The Audit Office evaluates the institution’s administrative management – how and for what public funds have been used, and with what results. The Office makes observations which are included in a preliminary report to which the institution responds. The final observations made by the Audit Office are, depending on the situation, provided to the institution via a letter of observation, to the Ministry via a ruling of the Audit Office’s First President, or to the public at large via a public report. In no way is a report from the National Audit Office considered to be a certification or a guarantee of quality assurance. |
Employability |
CNSMD:
Pôles d’enseignement supérieur:
CEFEDEM
CFMI
|
Academic Year |
From September to June.
|
Types of Pre-College Education |
|
(1) Conservatoires à rayonnement régional (CRR) |
There are about 36 CRRs that are mainly subsidised by the municipalities. CRRs are not institutions of higher education. They accept students from all ages and stages. Students have to take an entrance test or examination, depending on their level. Theory subjects are compulsory.
The CRRs provide amateur training as well as preparation for professional music training. The level of teaching offered is high, and graduates may reach a professional level at the CRR itself (but no Bachelor or Master diploma). Pedagogy training for graduates of CRRs and CRDs (see below) is provided through the higher education institutions controlled by the state: CNSMD, Pôles d’enseignement supérieur (PESM) and CEFEDEM (see overview of higher education system). After a full-time course, students receive a Diplôme d’Etat (1st cycle diploma) or a Certificat d’aptitude (2nd cycle diploma), which allows them to teach at every level, except for higher education. PESM and CEFEDEM do not only provide diplomas for the classical music field, but also for jazz, pop music and folk or world music. |
(2) Conservatoires à rayonnement départemental (CRD) |
France has around 105 CRDs. Their status is comparable to that of the CRRs.
|
(3) Music school |
There are many types of music schools; they are locally funded. Some schools are open to students of all ages and stages; others have narrowed their scope to, for example, children or adults.
Theory subjects are obliged. Because schools often do not offer tuition in all instruments (or do not have students applying to study certain instruments), it is difficult to establish orchestras or ensembles. |
(4) Private music schools |
There are many private music schools. They do not only provide classical music training; there are schools specialised in pop and jazz, and schools specialised in a certain teaching method (e.g. Suzuki).
|
(5) Private tuition |
Qualified teachers give private music lessons, outside of the general education system, and outside of any institutes.
|
Additional Information |
|
In CRRs, CRDs and music schools, the teaching program is organized in three levels, according to a ministry of Culture official diagram: |
|
Music and Arts in General Education |
In primary school (5 years), pupils receive about 80 hours a year of education in arts, sharing between music and visual arts.
In first part of secondary school (3 years) pupils receive about 70 hours a year of artistic education, half for music, half for visual arts. In second part of secondary education (three final years) the artistic education is optional. In this general education, some schools implement a specific program for musicians, with a partnership with the local music school or conservatoire. Generally two half-days (morning or afternoon) are devoted to music education. |
Students entering Higher Music Education |
Most students come from CRRs and CRDs.
CRRs and CRDs (officially no higher education institutions) have many students who started within their institution, or students from other institutions. |
Special Facilities for Talented Students at Pre-College Level |
A specific program allows schools to build a partnership with the local music school or conservatoire to offer pupils time for to music education. Generally two half-days a week are devoted to music education in primary school and first part of secondary school. For the end of secondary school a specific program leads to a specific option for musicians within the Baccalaureate: music disciplines are part of the education and weigh significantly for the award of the Baccalaureate.
There is a national youth orchestra. There are many competitions and festivals for talented students. |
Overview of Music Teacher Education System
Teacher education for music schools and conservatoires within the national scheme takes nowadays place in all of the higher musical education institutions: CNSMD, PESM, CEFEDEM, CFMI.
Note: It should be clarified that the term Conservatoire in France is a generic term which is equally given to music schools that take young children, as well as students on a pre-professional course. It is a term given to the two conservatoires nationaux supérieurs de musique et de danse in Paris and in Lyon which offer performance and teaching courses at a higher education level leading to professional qualification. The term Collège in France refers to secondary education for the 11 to 15 age group (1st part of secondary education).
Instrumental/Vocal Music Teacher Education |
|
Institutions |
Instrumental and vocal teacher training occurs at:
Région Ile-de-France
Région Auvergne Rhône-Alpes
Région Nouvelle Aquitaine
Région Provence Alpes
Régions Bretagne et Pays-de-la-Loire
Région Bourgogne – Franche Comté
Région Hauts de France
Région Occitanie (Pyrénées méditerranée)
Région Normandie
Région Provence-Alpes-Côte-d’Azur
|
Structure |
The structure of instrumental and vocal teacher training is:
The 3 Cefedems offer only the DE. The 10 Pôles d’enseignement supérieur now also offer three diplomas, which are in connection:
The two CNSMD offer both DE and CA (Certificat d’Aptitude).
It normally takes a student:
In order to be admitted to a DE course of study a student must hold a Baccalauréat and a final pre-college musical education, actually awarded by a CRR or a CRD (currently, the end of pre-college musical education is under re-organisation – April 2018).
|
Curriculum |
The curriculum of instrumental and vocal teacher training includes music training, educational training-teaching practice, music knowledge, educational knowledge (since July 2016, 1350 hours)
In the CNSM (for CA), curriculum includes music training, didactic, educational knowledge, teaching practice, general knowledge (900h). |
Genres |
|
Internationalization | Conservatoire National Supérieur de Musique et de Danse Those two institutions have a very active and solid internationalization policy, counting many international partners. Pôles d’enseignement supérieur Those institutions are more recent. Most of them have already an increasing internationalization policy, some others are only starting. CEFEDEM and CFMI: the INVITE program (Polifonia 2) showed how difficult it was for the teaching programs to develop internationalization. Nevertheless, some institutions have a selected or specific internationalization policy. |
Employability |
After graduation recipients of the DE receive the title Diplôme d’Etat de professeur de musique. The recipients of the CA receive the title Certficat d’Aptitude de professeur de musique. With regards to job opportunities, a DE is better to work in a music school, and a CA to work in conservatoires. These two diplomas are necessary to apply for a permanent job in the local authorities.
|
Continuing Professional Development (CPD) |
Continuing Professional Development is offered in/at some of the Pôle d’enseignement supérieur (but not in all) and Cefedem. They can offer CPD for accessing to the teaching diploma (yearly program) or for development on specific subjects.
CPD for all music teachers was until now (April 2018) offered by state organizations or non-profit associations at national level. All the system is currently under reorganisation (April 2018). |
Education for Music Teacher in General Education (primary and secondary school) |
|
Institutions |
Music teacher training in France for primary and secondary school teachers is divided by the level at which the teacher will work. For example:
These music teaching trainings take place at universities (as CFMI are also connected with the University; see ‘Instrumental and Vocal Teacher Education’).
|
Structure |
Music teachers in primary schools Here below the admission requirements for the two year course:
The application includes a curriculum vitae and letter of application. Musical skill tests and knowledge tests can only be made after an invitation from the commission. Music teachers in secondary school Admission exams for Agrégation: In the written exam the candidate has to hand in a paper on one of the topics published in the official journal. This is followed by an exam in music theory and the harmonisation of a tune. The oral exam consists of a teaching session in front of the examination board, conducting a choir, commenting on a piece of music and auditioning on the instrument. Both the CAPES and the Agrégation take two years to complete. |
Curriculum |
Music teachers in primary schools
The curriculum for teachers in primary school is aimed for teaching training. The curriculum is organised into the following eight modules:
Practice at school takes place alternately with the courses and according to the different modules.
First year:
Second year:
Music teachers in secondary school
Curriculum is more theoretically based, classes include music history, composition, ear training, accompaniment, etc. As was previously indicated, there are two ways of becoming a secondary school teacher: CAPES and Agrégation. Training for the CAPES (Certificat d’Aptitude de l’Enseignement Secondaire) lasts for 2 years. The first year consists of pre-studies as well as a first contact with classes and individual teaching situations. The Agrégation is accessible to all who hold a Maîtrise, a teaching certificate, as well as for teachers who have no permanent appointment. As with CAPES, the training lasts for 2 years. CAPES and/or Agrégation are necessary qualifications to successfully complete training at an IUFM. Acquiring an IUFM diploma is a prerequisite for getting permanent employment as a music teacher. In the course of a year, the trainee teaches 4 to 6 hours at a secondary school (Collège) and at the same time attends lectures at the IUFM on two days of the week. |
Employability |
Music teachers in primary schools Music teachers in secondary school |
Continuing Professional Development (CPD) |
Music teachers in primary schools Music teachers in secondary school |